Review of Far From True – Linwood Barclay

I write a lot of Amazon reviews for books I have read, but I’ve never thought about putting them here on my blog, so here goes with review #1:


Linwood Barclay is my favourite writer. However, I have decided that trilogies are not my favourite form of reading material, even if penned by the master himself.


When I finished the first in the Promise Falls trilogy, ‘Broken Promise’, I hadn’t realised that, in fact, it was the first of three interconnected tales, and so felt very disappointed that the ending was not neatly tied up in typical Barclay fashion.


By the time Far From True was out, I had forgotten many of the characters and plot lines – and there are a lot! I found it very difficult to keep track not only of who was who, but also the complex relationships between the characters which span both this book and its predecessor. The abrupt ending again left me feeling cheated at any lack of resolution.


It’s written brilliantly, of course, with an enormous and believable cast, and Barclay must have needed an immense spreadsheet in order to keep abreast of the interconnections, sub-plots and sub-sub-plots… ad infinitum. I can’t tell you who the main character is; every character has a story. The main plot is slightly more obvious – that a series of grisly events are connected by the number twenty-three (‘almost’ the title of the last in the trilogy).


I have to give it five stars because of the sheer feat achieved by Barclay in juggling so much information and character development with such expertise, and his flawless delivery of dialogue and narration from so many viewpoints, but I think that before embarking on novel Number Three I shall need to make some sort of web diagram so that I am better informed as to what is going on.


Author: helenlaycock

The tiniest detail can spark off an idea. I collect them, like butterflies. They can be strange or beautiful...and, as they flutter around, I pluck them out and use them to write. Sometimes they turn into poetry, sometimes into stories, but a lot of them have grown into something much bigger - books. I have not yet decided whether I am a children's or adults' author as I write for both. So, I'll just call myself a writer.

2 thoughts on “Review of Far From True – Linwood Barclay”

  1. I’m happy to read a series of books – but only if each one stands on its own. If they have to all be read, and in the correct order, for them to feel complete then I feel cheated.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s